A journey to New Philadelphia: Terry Olson explores his family’s roots

November 8, 2026

Terry Olson visits the grave of his four-times-great-grandfather John A. Cole, who lived with his family on a farm near New Philadelphia in the mid-1800s. Family history often begins with questions. For Terry Olson of Florida, questions about his ancestors led him on a journey to Pike County, Illinois, to learn more about them and their connection to the New Philadelphia community.

Olson’s four-times-great-grandparents, John A. and Betsey Cole, settled in the New Philadelphia area in 1837, just one year after Free Frank McWorter founded the town. The Cole family lived in the area until their deaths in 1859.

Reflecting on his visit to western Illinois, Olson said, “It was a fun surprise to find the road to New Philadelphia so hilly. Coming from flat Florida, this was … not exactly what I envisioned the “Prairie State” to be like. But I was here to discover and learn more about the area and my own ancestors’ history.

“Just a year or so after Free Frank had accomplished the unprecedented task, as a free Black man, of platting his own town, my four-times-great-grandparents moved to Hadley Township from Ohio. A map from the mid 1800s shows that the Coles had a farm just one farm removed from the McWorter farm.”

Like many descendants researching family history, Olson arrived with more questions than answers. He wondered, Why had the Cole family chosen to move from Ohio to western Illinois? Were they drawn by the opportunities available on the frontier or by the unique and diverse community taking shape around New Philadelphia? What relationships existed among the area’s early settlers? And why did many descendants later move farther west? While he did not find all the answers, he embraced the opportunity to walk in the footsteps of his ancestors.

“What I did find was a group of friendly people willing and eager to help me learn what I could from the past. With their guidance, I was able to see the land my family once owned. I was able to touch the gravestones of that pioneering couple and that of their one son who stayed in the area, married to a Stauffer girl.

“I also delighted in the tree-lined streets of Barry and Pittsfield, the wonderful architecture of the late 19th-century homes and civic buildings, and the farming operations throughout the area. Those elements brought back warm memories of my own childhood growing up on a farm near a small town in Minnesota.”

Olson said he also was struck by the area’s connection to broader American history. He noted the ties between New Philadelphia, Abraham Lincoln, and the early years of Illinois statehood, recognizing how the stories of Frank McWorter and other settlers intersected with significant moments in the nation’s development.

Although some questions about the relationship between the Cole and McWorter families may never be fully answered, Olson left Pike County with a deeper appreciation for the people who came before him. He wrote that, being close to the places where history occurred, fostered “pride in our shared humanity” and gratitude for the generations whose courage and perseverance shaped the country we know today.

Olson’s visit serves as a reminder that New Philadelphia remains a place of discovery, where descendants can reconnect with their roots and visitors can explore the stories of families, both Black and white, who continue to enrich our understanding of this historic and remarkable community.

Photo courtesy of Terry Olson.