Thelma McWorter Kirkpatrick Wheaton: Preserving Family History and the Legacy of New Philadelphia
November 4, 2026
One of the most important ways the story of New Philadelphia continues to be preserved is through the memories and writings of descendants who experienced firsthand the people, places and traditions connected to the community. Among those voices is that of Thelma McWorter Kirkpatrick Wheaton (1901-2001), a great-granddaughter of Free Frank and Free Lucy McWorter.
Thelma spent much of her childhood in Pike County, living near the New Philadelphia site with her father Arthur McWorter, her siblings, Bernice, Ellen, Festus and Cordell, and her grandmother Frances Jane McWorter Bates. Thelma’s mother died shortly after giving birth to Cordell.
Thelma attended the rural New Philadelphia school and later graduated from Barry High School in 1924. Although she spent her adult life in Chicago, she remained deeply connected to Barry, regularly returning for church activities, class reunions, the Barry Apple Festival, and other events. Throughout her life, she was known as a key family historian who enjoyed connecting with others and sharing stories about her family’s past.
In an undated letter later published in a Barry newspaper and included in the Barry Family Histories book, Thelma reflected on her childhood experiences in Pike County. She vividly described traveling to Barry in her grandmother’s surrey pulled by their two horses, Prince and Princess, and accompanying her family on trips to town for supplies, church functions and community programs.
Her recollections provide a rare glimpse into daily life for McWorter descendants during the early 20th century. She remembered her father selling cream, eggs, poultry and other farm products in Barry while her grandmother managed a successful farm operation. Through these remembrances, Thelma documented the challenges and resilience of rural life while preserving details that might otherwise have been lost to history. Faith also played an important role in Thelma’s life. Following the example of generations before her, she joined the First Baptist Church of Barry and spoke warmly of her baptism and the influence of her family and church community.
One of her most memorable stories recounts the 1976 U.S. Bicentennial celebration, when members of the McWorter family participated in the Barry Apple Festival Parade. Their float honored Frank and Lucy McWorter and the family’s pioneering legacy. Thelma portrayed Lucy, while her brother Cordell portrayed Frank, helping introduce local audiences to the history of New Philadelphia and the remarkable story of the McWorters.
Thelma’s writings remind us that the history of New Philadelphia is more than a collection of dates and events from the past. It is a living story carried forward through family memories, community connections, faith, perseverance, and a commitment to preserving the legacy of those who came before us. It is significant that Thelma took the time to record her experiences, as she helped ensure that future generations can learn from and appreciate the enduring impact of the McWorter family.
